A candlelit séance for your dinner party

An 1850s village decided a quiet girl was the reason for its bad luck. Tonight we're going to ask her about it.

The girl the town decided to blame

Gurnsey Hollow was the kind of place where a bad year needed a reason. In the 1850s it found one: a girl at the edge of town who kept to herself, didn't marry, didn't explain herself, and was therefore obviously responsible for the crops, the fever, and the child who didn't come home.

What the town did about her depends entirely on which version you hear. There are four of them and they don't agree — which, in a story like this, is usually the first sign that something really happened.

The legend never left. And that's the story we're going to sit down with.

Headstones and bare trees in a rural graveyard, lit from one side after dark

What the evening is actually like

It's a séance, so your guests sit around one table. Candles, a few objects, and me. For the first stretch it's storytelling — what the records say, what the town said instead, and where those two things come apart. Your guests will form opinions. They'll say them out loud.

Then the room starts participating, and that's when it turns.

Questions get asked that are far too specific for a stranger to know. Objects don't stay where they were put. Somebody's private answer ends up out loud, and nobody can account for how.

It builds slowly. No jump scares. By the end, most people aren't sure where the show stops.

Twenty minutes or ninety — your call

This séance comes in parts, so it can run as long as your schedule allows. The full ninety‑minute version is the deepest, but I've run it as a tight twenty when it needed to sit between other things — including four separate twenty-minute séances across one night in New York, so every guest at a large party got their own.

A lit candle in a brass holder beside a stack of antique leather books and a magnifying glass

What I'm not claiming

I'm a performer, not a medium. Nothing here is presented as contact with the dead, and I won't tell your guests otherwise.

What I will tell them is that the Victorians did exactly this in their parlors, as entertainment, with this equipment — took it completely seriously for an hour, and argued about it on the carriage ride home.

We're doing the same thing, for the same reason, and it works just as well as it did then.

"Each small group was thoroughly entertained and amazed. The looks on some of their faces included shock, awe, and melting doubt. We already booked Cris for next year's trip!"
Guests said: "I was not a believer in the supernatural at all, but I might be a little convinced that something is out there now." — "I don't know what just happened, but I want to see more."Ellen Greenberg, Social Studies Teacher — Longwood High School senior class trip

The details

Guests
8–25. Twelve to eighteen is the sweet spot
Run time
20–90 minutes. You choose the length
Large parties
I run several short séances across the evening. Four in one night is my record
Setup
90 minutes for the full version · in‑home short version, about 10
Pack-up
30 minutes after the show
The room
Somewhere that can be made fully dark. One table your guests can sit around
What I need
Floor space, one electrical outlet, and the table. That's the whole list
Where
Based in Niagara Falls. Buffalo, Rochester and all of Western New York, plus Pennsylvania and Ohio
Ages
16+. No exceptions

Right for

  • Dinner parties where the point is the conversation afterward
  • Milestone birthdays and anniversaries
  • Halloween parties, the grown-up version
  • An old house you'd like people to be nervous in
  • Guests who like being unsettled slowly rather than startled quickly

Wrong for

  • Anyone under sixteen
  • A room where the bar is the main event
  • Groups over twenty-five at one time. I'll split it into several séances instead, and it's better that way
  • Anybody hoping to contact someone they've actually lost. I don't do that

Is your date open?

Tell me when, roughly how many, and where. You'll get an answer and an exact price the same day.

Call Me Contact Me Contact Me